INDEPENDENT ADVERSARIAL VERIFICATION — MIZOKICloudRun completion-run

Verifier: independent (no builder reports read; worked from branch diff, PHASE_A_MATRIX.md, rules, tree) Repo: /home/user/MIZOKICloudRun · branch completion-run · HEAD a74e8de · merge-base vs origin/main 9e72d07 Diff: 76 files, +8,985/−77 (site copy fixes + services/measurement-rails/ + tests/claims_backing/ + rule-E gate + docs) Final git status --short: clean (zero verifier-created changes; both gate-flip mutations reverted via git checkout --).

V1 — Content gates: PASS (with 2 disagreements recorded)

Tool runs (from site dir # MIZ OKI 3.5/): - python3 scripts/content_qa.py --self-test → SELF-TEST PASS — the gate fires, all 16 seeded classes CAUGHT (12 copy classes + rule-E a/b/c/d), clean samples 0 findings. Exit 0. - python3 scripts/content_qa.py → CONTENT QA OK — 25 scoped files clean (banned strings, preview framing, number labels, §-sequence, claims ledger backed). Exit 0.

Independent greps over the served set (60 files derived from app.py routes: 23 root pages, 3+3 templates, briefing index+3 js, 12 marketing/, 9 media/, 5 blog/, console; dead-routed 301 pages excluded — security.html/roi.html/how-it-works.html/platform.html/industries.html/case-studies.html/resources.html/investor.html/sales-one-pager.html/demo-opener.html/blogs.html redirect to / per app.py:841-852): - mind-reading: 4 hits, all legal — signal.html:416, shopify.html:211, demo-signal.html:397 are explicit negations ("not mind-reading"); marketing/signal.html:57 is inside the "What we never say" claim-cell (contextual negation — legal, but see D2 below). - guaranteed/guarantee: 2 hits — shopify.html:187 "Never a guaranteed outcome" (story-bank rule 5 verbatim, legal); signal-creative.html:270 "upper-confidence-bound where regret guarantees matter" — statistical term of art (UCB regret guarantees), not an outcome promise. No affirmative "guaranteed" anywhere. - "Quokka Swarm": ZERO hits on all 60 served files. - 4.95 / 0.66 / 0.04 co-occurrence: ZERO. 4.95 appears nowhere served; 0.66 only as CSS font-size (console/index.html:119,279,318); 0.04 only as CSS rgba alpha (pricing.html:62) and a JS increment (data.js:536). No KL context anywhere. - present-tense machinery/deployed sweep: signal-measurement.html:267 "operating machinery" sentence now carries the D3 honesty line in the same note: "Rails ship flag-gated and dry-run first; live posting to ad platforms is enabled per engagement." — verified in diff (d910eed). signal.html:487 "Signal Factory desk is live on the production runtime" = the site's real demo runtime (C21/C44, disclosed). shopify.html:198 "Prove is live in the ledger above" sits in a §05 with the Preview · in development tag; next-acts future-tensed. Net-yield sections on signal.html carry Preview · in development tags (lines 400,417) and future tense ("When this ships…").

Disagreements (tool vs my grep): - D1 (regex gap + scope gap): marketing/index.html:62 — proof strip <div class="num">&lt;100ms</div> Signal Latency is an unlabeled latency stat. It is (a) OUTSIDE content_qa scope (only marketing/governance.html is scoped) and (b) INVISIBLE to the gate's OBSERVED_PERF regex even if scoped — the pattern class is 15-minute|sub-second|sub-\d+ms; <100ms matches none. PRE-EXISTING: the file is untouched by this run's diff. Same class the run fixed as T6 on demo-signal.html. - D2 (scope gap, benign): marketing/signal.html:57 "Mind-reading." is legal in its never-say column but would false-positive under the gate's lookbehind-only negation handling if marketing pages were ever scoped. marketing/signal.html:162 "serving sub-100ms" WOULD pass the gate if scoped (its card carries "design targets, labeled as targets" and a spec-source line). Pre-existing, untouched by this run. - Observation (not a violation): executive-briefing/js/data.js:159 "a governed legal toolset in production" — backed on the same basis the matrix accepted for C21/C44 (the Counsel Room demo runs on the production site runtime, tested); pre-existing line, not in the A1 fix list.

V2 — Claims verdicts (every matrix §2/§2b row)

Note: matrix rows run M1–M9, A10–A14, C19–C47. C17/C18 do not exist in the matrix or the A2 audit (tables start at M1/C19) — the task range "C17–C47" over-covers; nothing was skipped.

Verdict counts (by claim id): BACKED-BY-CODE 33 (M1–M9, A10–A14, C19b/C39, C21, C22, C27–C38 [12 ids], C40, C41, C44, C47) · LABELED-DEBT/RELABELED 4 (C42, C43, C45, C46) · VIOLATION 5 ids in 3 findings (C20; C23; C24/C25/C26).

ZERO-unbacked-present-tense conclusion: NOT fully met. Two residual present-tense overstatements remain on served pages: C20's "reads from this ledger" (read-path is the run's own labeled debt RL-1) and C23's "knowledge graph" (store is a Firestore collection; the run's own ledger note prescribes different wording). Everything else on the scoped surfaces is code-backed, debt-labeled, or relabeled — I verified every ledger evidence path (62/62 exist) and every cited test actually exercises its claimed mechanic (no import-only tests found in the pack).

V3 — Test re-runs + flag enforcement: PASS

Flag-flip proofs (mutate → red → revert → green): - MEASUREMENT_WRITEBACK — flipped flags.py:22 WRITEBACK_DEFAULT = False→True: 4 failed (test_writeback_default_off, test_literal_defaults_pinned_in_code, test_flag_states_all_false_by_default, test_require_writeback_raises_while_off) — red tail: ==== 4 failed, 6 passed ====. git checkout -- services/measurement-rails/flags.py → 10 passed. - NET_YIELD_WRITEBACK — flipped writeback/__init__.py:24 default "false"→"true": 3 failed (test_flag_defaults_off, test_meta_send_refuses_while_off, test_google_send_refuses_while_off) — red tail: ==== 3 failed, 7 passed ====. git checkout -- services/net-yield/writeback/__init__.py → 10 passed.

DRY-RUN / no-live-HTTP proof: - Every rail send path requires flag ON + dry_run=False + injected transport (flags.require_rail/require_transport; writeback adds require_writeback first — writeback.py:166-168). Grep of all rails + net-yield writeback sources: zero httpx/requests./urllib/socket usage (only a docstring word "requests"); the only network-capable import is lazy google.cloud.bigquery inside bq.py:34-36, skipped when a client is injected (all tests inject). FastAPI in main.py is inbound-only. - Socket tripwire: tests/claims_backing/conftest.py:24-30 autouse fixture patches socket.socket.connect/connect_ex + socket.create_connection. PROVEN: probe test against the same conftest — socket.connect and create_connection both raise "Network access is blocked in tests/claims_backing" (2 passed).

V4 — Seeded violations + structural checks: PASS

Independent seeding (my own fixtures, distinct from --self-test seeds), one per class: A banned-string ("Results are guaranteed…") CAUGHT · B missing preview framing ("latent intent engine") CAUGHT · C unlabeled % ("41% CAC improvement") CAUGHT · D §-gap (§01→§03) CAUGHT · E(a) missing evidence path CAUGHT · E(b) dangling debt_id CAUGHT · E(c) evidence-less row CAUGHT · E(d) unledgered required claim id CAUGHT. 8/8.

Structural: - §-sequences strictly 1..N (my own extraction): signal 1-9 ✓, thresholds 1-6 ✓, budget 1-6 ✓, creative 1-4 ✓, audiences 1-5 ✓, measurement 1-4 ✓, shopify 1-6 ✓. - pricing.html anchors (165-167): /#what, /#divisions, /#control — all three ids exist exactly once on index.html ✓ (K1 fixed). - blog/posts.json: broken og refs REMOVED (adc-framework, dcp — diff verified); remaining image /assets/img/blog/meta-relu/og_meta_relu_1200x627.png exists on disk; feeds emit no 404 URLs (app.py emits image only when present). K2 resolved by removal rather than asset generation — meets the no-404 goal (noted as a variant of the proposed fix). - Story bank: drop/signal-story-bank-v1.1.md md5 17ca73b7… == # MIZ OKI 3.5/docs/marketing/signal-story-bank.md (byte-identical, cmp clean); title carries v1.1; site CLAUDE.md §Coding-Guidelines item 5 pointer present (line 863). - Nothing merged to main: none of the branch's 9 commits (9551ace…a74e8de) is an ancestor of origin/main (checked individually). origin/main -40 contains only the two coordination commits: 453247e and 745430e — git show --stat proves each touches ONLY CLAUDE.md + .claude/memory/index.json; merge vehicle e7456d9 brought exactly those two files. - No deploy executed: diff touches zero .github/** paths (count 0); no deploy-*.yml modified; services/measurement-rails/cloudbuild.yaml is build+push only ("deliberately NO push-triggered deploy workflow"); PHASE_A_MATRIX §5 router-inertness consistent with deploy-*.yml path filters. - RUNBOOK.md: all scheduler/secret/DDL/deploy steps are future-imperative operator commands ("created by YOU, or they do not exist", "Deploy with your own credentials") — zero performed-action claims. ADR: "implemented — NOT deployed". Rails README: "deploy state: NOT deployed". No doc claims anything was deployed/scheduled/live-verified THIS run. - docs/completion-run/dossier-stories.proposal.md header: "Proposal only — approval-gated… No dossier page has been touched" — confirmed: no dossier page in the diff carries story blocks.

Findings register (overall)

1. F1 (moderate) — C20 copy not relabeled. signal.html:241 keeps the present-tense "Budget reallocation reads from this ledger" while the run's own ledger row + BUILD_DEBT RL-1 say the read-path is unbuilt. Policy demands relabel-to-operating-design when the resolution is debt. (The matrix's approved resolution for C20 did not order a copy edit — the shortfall is in the approved resolution itself as measured against the mission policy.)
2. F2 (minor) — C23 wording. signal-thresholds.html:264,316 say "knowledge graph"; the coded, tested store is the relu_playbook_patterns Firestore collection, and the run's own ledger note prescribes "pattern library" wording that was never applied to the page.
3. F3 (minor) — C24/C25/C26 unpinned + unledgered. $50 / 80% / 85-15 are code-true (verified at relu_threshold_agents.py:70,71,77) and page-labeled, but the B5 promise "pins each coded constant… ledger cites module+test per claim" was not executed for them; constant drift would fail nothing.
4. F4 (minor) — promised ledger citations absent for C41 and C45. Matrix resolutions say "Ledger cites live-verified memory records" (C41) and "ledger records basis" (C45); neither row exists in claims-ledger.yaml. Rule E passes because page_coverage doesn't require those ids — the gate enforces what the ledger declares, and the declarations were omitted.
5. F5 (minor, pre-existing) — unlabeled <100ms latency stat at marketing/index.html:62, out of gate scope and invisible to the OBSERVED_PERF regex class even if scoped (<100ms ≠ sub-\d+ms). File untouched by this run.
6. F6 (minor, structural) — marketing/* excluded from content_qa scope (except governance.html): the parallel site carries claim-bearing copy (D1/D2 hits) that the gate never scans. Recommend scope extension + a [<≤]\s*\d+\s*ms arm in OBSERVED_PERF.

Not findings: site-suite 2 failures and virtuoso 1 failure — proven pre-existing at merge-base. data.js:159 "legal toolset in production" — pre-existing, backed on the accepted demo-runtime basis. posts.json image-removal variant — meets the no-404 goal.

Could not reproduce: nothing — every matrix claim row was reproducible to a verdict; no evidence path was missing; no cited test was import-only.

OVERALL: FAIL-with-6-findings

The build core is genuinely SOLID — all 8 suites/gates behave as claimed (429-site/192-rails/59-net-yield/110-claims/29-virtuoso-passing, skills/memory/canon green), both hard flags are literal-false and flip-provably pinned, no live-HTTP path exists in the rails, nothing merged to main beyond the two documented coordination commits, and no deploy occurred. The FAIL is on the mission's zero-tolerance bar: two residual present-tense overstatements on served pages (C20 read-path, C23 "knowledge graph") plus incomplete execution of the approved B5/B1 resolutions (C24-C26 pins; C41/C45 ledger rows) and one pre-existing unlabeled latency stat outside the gate's reach.

LOOP-1 RE-CHECK (max-two-loops protocol, loop 1 of 2)

HEAD: a74e8de → (main merge 6a1f7e3 incl. ef5ae95 docs/prompts) → adc5e6c (foreign: claims_helpers cell26 import hardening) → 885d92c (fix commit). git diff a74e8de..885d92c on site+services+tests touches EXACTLY the 7 expected files (ledger, marketing/index, content_qa.py, signal-thresholds, signal.html, claims_helpers, test_c22_c23) — nothing else from loop 0 moved; loop-0 conclusions on all other surfaces stand. Working tree clean before and after; all temp mutations reverted (git status --short empty at finish).

Note on pytest counts: tests/claims_backing/pytest.ini already sets -q; adding -q on the CLI yields -qq which suppresses the final summary line — counts above were taken without the doubled flag.

UPDATED OVERALL VERDICT: PASS

All six loop-0 findings are CLOSED with adversarial evidence (including one gate-flip proof for the new E(d) coverage). No unbacked present-tense machinery claim remains on the scoped/served surfaces. Two low-severity residual observations (R1 raw-< HTML stripper blind spot, R2 marketing/* scope still governance-only) are logged for the owner's backlog; both are hardening opportunities, not claim violations, and no page today depends on either gap.